New York City Cupcake Tasting Tour

October 8, 2007 | Chuck
New York City Cupcake Tasting Tour

Hungry Bear and I love cupcakes, but I think our friend, Aimee, is a bigger cupcake fanatic. Last month while visiting Jeff and Aimee in NYC, Aimee organized a cupcake tasting tour around five popular cupcake shops in the city. We even had a scorecard, created by Jeff, to rate the shops and keep our tasting notes.

Since we all love chocolate, and to fairly rate the cupcake shops, we agreed to taste the chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting at each store. It was acceptable, and our duty, to sample the other cupcake flavors, but the chocolate chocolate cupcake was a mandatory tasting. We also decided to prevent over eating by sharing cupcakes.

We started the cupcake tour at 4:00 PM on a warm Friday afternoon at Harlem's Make My Cake, excited and full of energy. The plan was to head south and end the tour at Magnolia Bakery in the West Village. After splitting a few large cupcakes at Make My Cake, we were all on a sugar high and headed to Crumbs Bake Shop.

After only two stops on the tour, we all hit the sugar wall and started to feel sluggish. Aimee had skipped lunch and wanted some real food. Hungry Bear and I needed something savory to settle our stomachs. Conveniently for us, we passed Gray's Papaya on our way to Buttercup. To re-energize for the second half the tour, we proceeded to each eat a hot dog at Gray's Papaya. It wasn't the healthiest thing, but we were on a cupcake tasting tour, so healthy food choices were not on the agenda.

Buttercup Bake Shop was the next destination. It was a highly anticipated spot based on its history and high rankings on all NYC cupcakery lists. At this point, there were concerns by some participants whether we would be able to complete all five tour stops that day.

We were at 72nd street and the next stop on the tour was Cupcake Cafe on 40th street. We literally stumbled the thirty two blocks down to Cupcake Cafe and barely beat the 7:00 PM closing time. After sharing a few more cupcakes, we had to call it a night. We were all tired and incoherent from all of our cupcake eating. Jeff said he felt like he had been drinking all day.

On our way back to Columbus Circle, we grabbed a Philly cheese steak and half a pizza for dinner... yes, dinner. Even though we were full of sugary cupcakes, we were still a little hungry. And believe it or not, we all felt better after ingesting some protein. Feeling better was short lived, as we all passed out by 9:00 PM while watching the Dog Whisperer on TV. The night ended with Aimee declaring that she would not eat cupcakes again for a long time.

A long time in Aimee's world must mean a couple of days, because only two days later with her relentless pressure, we completed the tour by queuing up at Magnolia Bakery. It was a strange experience at Magnolia's. First we had to wait in line before the cupcake shop bouncer let us in. Next, everyone in the shop grabs their own cupcakes in the window display and then lines up to pay. It appears to be a very inefficient process, but who's to argue with the mother of all cupcake shops.

Magnolia Cupcake

Ratings

After reviewing the tasting notes and with careful consideration, I present to you our 2007 NYC Cupcake Tasting Tour rankings. The ratings are only from the participants who tasted cupcakes at all five bakeries.

Cupcake Tour Rankings (1 = Best, 5 = Worst)

Cupcake Shop Aimee Jeff Hungry Bear Chuck
Make My Cake 2 2 2 2
Crumbs Bake Shop 3 4 1 1
Buttercup Bake Shop 5 5 5 5
Cupcake Cafe 1 1 4 3
Magnolia Bakery 4 3 3 4

There was no clear winner on this tour. Cupcake tasting and judging is very subjective and comes down to your preferences between the cake part and the frosting. Hungry Bear and I use the cake as the main rating criteria. We believe the frosting is there to compliment and enhance the cake, but not to over power it. With that in mind, we both chose Crumbs Bake Shop as the best cupcake shop on our tour. We thought that Crumbs had the best cake in terms of texture, moisture and chocolate taste.

Jeff favors the frosting flavor and the moistness of the cake. He is also values aesthetically pleasing cupcakes. Aimee considers the cake and the frosting equally important. However, she doesn't like cupcakes that are overloaded with frosting. Another key factor for Aimee is the coldness of the cupcake. She prefers cold, refrigerated cupcakes for some strange reason. Interestingly, both Jeff and Aimee chose Cupcake Cafe as their favorite bakery. They serve cold cupcakes.

The clear loser in this cupcake tour was Buttercup Bake Shop. It was the lowest ranked bakery across the board. Maybe it's just the 72nd street location, but the cake was dry and lacked any flavor. The killer was the overload of frosting, which was too sweet. The shop was a big disappointment given all of its hype.

We all agreed that Cupcake Cafe had the prettiest looking cupcakes and that Buttercup Bake Shop should not be on the list of on any future cupcake tasting tours. I find it interesting that given our different judging criteria and tastes, we all ranked Make My Cake as our number two shop. I'm concluding that this shop has the best combination of good cake and frosting.

Tips

The cupcake tour was very fun and the highlight of our visit to NYC. It's a great activity for people of all ages. I highly recommend conducting your own cupcake eating tour in NYC or your favorite city. Here are some tips if you plan on going on a cupcake tasting tour.

  • Map out the shops and route in advance. If you are walking, the last stop should be the cupcake shop closest to your home. Walking long distances with a cupcake buzz is not fun.
  • Keep a scorecard and notes. After a few cupcakes and the sugar high and crash, you'll forget everything if you don't take notes.
  • No matter how hungry you are, make sure you share cupcakes, especially the large ones. I would recommend splitting large cupcakes into six portions. You'll pay the price if you don't limit your cupcake intake.
  • Start early and plan the day around the cupcake tour. Visit other attractions on the route to pace your cupcake eating. Also, sprinkle in a few savory food stops between the cupcake shops. Your stomach will thank you for the salty snacks and protein.
  • Don't start the day by eating baked French toast casserole, followed by a three-course lunch at Le Cirque, before your cupcake tour!

 

Tour Participants: Aimee, Jeff, Ava, Hungry Bear, Chuck, Kurt, Craig, Nicole

[tags]new york city, tour, cupcakery, cupcakes, chocolate, frosting, ratings[/tags]

14 Comments on “New York City Cupcake Tasting Tour”

  1. This is fabulous! I’d love to post one of your photos (along with a link) on my cupcake blog Cupcakes Take the Cake (http://cupcakestakethecake.blogspot.com). Please let me know if that would be okay, and glad you enjoyed NYC’s many fine cupcake offerings!

  2. Maggie said:

    for the cupcake rating, on a scale from 1-5, which one is good and which is bad? maybe you can include next to your chart.

  3. Chuck said:

    Maggie, thanks for the suggestion. I updated the table title.

  4. Cakespy said:

    I just came across this…this is fabulous. And I don’t even like the word fabulous, it feels a little over the top in most cases, but it feels right at this moment. Buttercup Bakeshop is one of my favorites.

  5. Chuck said:

    @Rachel – I’m not sure if you received my email. If not, feel free to use a photo on your blog. Cheers!

  6. Michele said:

    Out of the Kitchen on Leroy street, omg sooo good!

  7. Valerie said:

    omg this site just completed my life i love cupcakes! no one ever takes me seriously im glad you guys do!

  8. hey there from a cupcake lover in ny! come back come back! come back and try billy’s bakery in chelsea and then go to the cooper hewitt museum and get a cupcake from their cafe–i’m not sure which bakery brings them over but you can eat it in the courtyard or in the cafe and you will not be sorry! i promise! next time…ok?

  9. Bill R said:

    Hello,

    My 8 year old and I took your advice and tried several of your candidates last August, then added a few new ones today on “Cupcake Tour 2″ and found your information consistent with our findings. However, we can heartily recommend Sugar Sweet Sunshine at 126 Rivington Street with our 1st prize, and a close second went to Tonnie’s Minis on W3 st (which won the serious chocolate division)!. Beat the well known names with ease. Both were moist bottoms with excellent frosting. A bonus is that they were almost 1/2 the price of the others!

  10. nyc tours said:

    I love cupcakes! great review. Now I know where my next stop :)

  11. Great review! I love the idea of a cupcake tour. I ordered my wedding cake from Cupcake Cafe back in 2001 and it was delicious! I don’t live in the city anymore, but you have inspired me to look up the best cupcake places in the Hudson Valley. I’d have to conduct this tour by car though. Happy cupcake tasting!
    Vanessa

  12. I’m getting ready for my trip to NY to do just this; cupcake tasting!! This article was very helpful for my sweet plans.

  13. MichelleChef NYC said:

    I really loved checking out your tour of NYC Cupcake Meccas. Might I suggest that the next time you hit the streets for a cupcake extravaganza that you add Sugar Sweet Sunshine and Billy’s to your list… they are both good contenders in the cupcake arena.

  14. Dan said:

    I don’t know about anyone else, but I grew up in Detroit with Coney dogs. They’re definitely the best in my opinion!

Leave a Comment

Comment Guidelines:
Email addresses are never published. Comments are editable for 15 minutes after submission. Basic HTML can be used, e.g. <strong> <i> <em> <strike> etc. Gravators (globally recognized avatars) are enabled. Sign-up at Gravatar to display your avatar on SND and other sites.